Yamine Yamal of FC Barcelona dribbles past defender.

December 9, 2025

The Player Paradox: Stars vs. Sustainability

  • Nitsan Peled

This is chapter 2 of our 6-part series “2026 and Beyond: Sports Industry Leaders on What’s Next”, bringing the voices of industry leaders from WSC Sports’ Madrid Huddle to wrap up 2025.

The Player Paradox: Stars vs. Sustainability

December 9, 2025

Share this article
  • Nitsan Peled

Perhaps no topic generated more passionate debate at the Madrid Huddle than the role of individual athletes in content strategy. On one side: the undeniable reality that younger fans increasingly follow players, not teams. On the other: the existential risk of building your brand around assets that can transfer to competitors.

"We are well aware that the younger the fan, the more they are into players," says Ashley Hover of the Premier League in response to the results of the "2025/26 WSC Sports Fan Engagement Study: How Gen X, Y, and Z Are Redefining Sports Fandom”, which was discussed in Madrid. "And with the right technology, we are easily serving our fans content about precisely what they prefer. So the mind-shift has already happened. We see leagues, clubs, and players alike understanding that this is an ecosystem that is benefiting from working together."

Get the full Fan Engagement Study:

For Julien Segui, Head of Content at EuroLeague, the evolution is even more fundamental. "Athletes should be viewed not as partners for content distribution but as integral players in the content creation ecosystem. They are, many of them, simply creators." He points to a documentary EuroLeague produced about Nigel Hayes-Davis, who approached the league in March saying, "I'm going to win the EuroLeague" and asked to be mic'd up throughout the playoffs. Amazingly enough, Hayes-Davis did go on to win the championship, along with finals MVP. "The opportunity to tell the stories of players that can connect with the regular fan and beyond the fan — I think that was the purpose of us going there," added Segui.

Tomas Olabarri of Publicis puts it bluntly: "The lives of the people behind the sport are maybe the most interesting thing for younger audiences. Young fans may watch a fraction of a game once, a highlight one more time, but they can't get enough clips of Lamin Yamal's life."

Anouk Mertens of Neo Studios (the production team behind "Welcome to Wrexham") identifies another crucial shift: "Gen Z turns to TikTok and Instagram always, so sports content falls into that pattern naturally. But maybe even more importantly, and we even see it on LinkedIn — people don't like to follow and engage with 'logos.' They prefer connecting with human beings, and the athletes are all active on social platforms. So that's who sports organizations need to work with to get to younger generations."

And the content ecosystem is expanding in unexpected directions. "When fans say they want different angles, to me this does not only mean camera angles," notes Liam Davies of Braincup Media. "Yes, you have sports with angles from drivers or refs, but I think for example that independent creators give just that, too, in a way—different angles, by giving different perspectives. Watching a streamer while you're watching a game or a match is something that while it is big, we will see it developing further."

But not everyone is convinced this player-first approach is sustainable. "Not everyone has the biggest stars in the world, and players come and go," cautions Lucia Alcaraz of Liga F. "So the best way to tap into young fans' habits is to include the players in the storytelling of the clubs, but never forget that the clubs are here to stay, they have history, community. Players should play a role, but as part of the story of the club."

Deacon Smith of DAZN has seen the downside firsthand. "Some players carry an entire market with them, and when they leave, teams and leagues must be preemptive with that. If you're reacting after the player has left, the horses literally left the barn. If you have an athlete who captures an audience for you, you must use that time to capitalize on that attention and help those fans identify with you. Cause once they're gone, they're gone, and now it's reacquiring them from scratch."

Martin Aurenche of LFP frames it as a question of narrative hierarchy. "The team's stories are the most important thing, and telling their stories is part of the infrastructure of a good league. Tell the story of the clubs, the stadiums, the cities, the communities, the history—and the players are a part of it. Otherwise, you are risking having a huge churn in fans, because players move teams. Move countries. And you risk starting from scratch. So yes, clubs should include players, but it has to be around the teams and their stories, show the fans that the players themselves are proud to play for the team—this will help strengthen the team itself."

The pragmatic middle ground may come from an unexpected source: Kings League's Martino Armanini. "There is not really another way — Yannick Sinner has his own YouTube channel, Erling Haaland has his own YouTube channel. They all build their own brands, and monetize them on their own channels. And so, organizations will have to capitalize on that, because it's a tide that lifts all boats. As your players are becoming bigger, you can tap into that potential."

But Armanini adds a crucial caveat: "There is probably a critical mass after which you will not follow more players. I mean, how many players can you follow? 10, 20, 100? So if you get to the maximum, the investment on that content will start to yield a diminishing return, which makes me a little skeptical on the validity of this business model in the long, long, long run. So to me, it means to never give up on the team- or league-driven content. Your players are part of your product, part of your brand."

Andrea Ballo of Juventus offers a real-world case study. "After Cristiano Ronaldo left, we had to fill a huge hole—and we did that by scaling our content output, more originals, more short videos, developed a creator lab. We used to be all in, 100% only reliant on broadcast media deals, and now it is one leg in our entire content strategy."

The resolution to this tension isn't choosing one side. It's accepting that both are true simultaneously: young fans do follow players, and sustainable brands require institutional storytelling. The delicate secret sauce lies in leveraging individual star power while continuously weaving those stars into larger narratives that outlast any single career. It requires scale, speed, advanced personalization capabilities, and a healthy dash of human-led creativity. All the things the Madrid Huddle has in abundance.

To get more content like this, stay tuned for the next chapter in our series, “Following” vs. “Watching” – The Gen Z Reality.

You Might Also Like...

November 6, 2026

November 3, 2026